We’re All Art Teachers

Education Next Issue Cover

Don’t try to quantify its worth


5 Comments | Print | PDF |

SUMMER 2015 / VOL. 15, NO. 3

“You can’t play music on a piece of paper.”

Alicia Arman

Alicia Arman

Those were the first words a little boy I’ll call Michael said to me when he walked in the doors of summer theater camp. I was 18, just months away from starting my first year at Berkeley. I was ready to do my part in shaping the young artists of my hometown as a drama teacher (in training) at one of the myriad theater camps in the area. I’d done this before and knew what to expect: kids are kids, I thought, and these kids would be like all the others—bouncy, bubbly, full of life, and totally normal. I wasn’t expecting anyone to yell, “You can’t play music on a piece of paper.” I wasn’t expecting Michael.

It turns out Michael was quoting SpongeBob SquarePants, something he would do a lot during our month together. This nine-year-old boy had severe autism and spoke only in quotes from movies and television. His mother had enrolled him in theater camp to help him come out of his shell and learn to socialize with other kids. Michael was behind academically, appeared half his age emotionally, and was prone to temper tantrums. When his mother handed me his Individual Education Plan, I wanted to cry.

The first week I asked myself, “What’s wrong with this boy’s mother for bringing him here?” The more I got to know him, the more I wondered, “What is wrong with our program that we can’t make room for him?” Michael wanted to be there. He wanted to be with other kids; he wanted to speak; he wanted to be seen as a full human being.

Michael didn’t end up onstage, but backstage. He discovered his love for stage lights early in the summer and sat next to our burly technical director, pushing buttons and turning lights on and off, as integral to the process as if he were the lead. Michael found a way to speak to us, and we had to listen. It made me think once again about why Michael’s mother had enrolled him in theater camp: she wanted him to participate in a conversation on his own terms and to be heard.

The rhetoric of “college and career ready,” for good or ill, has taken over our educational moment. Education is defined as preparation, its purpose tied to an abstract future time. This implies (if taken most sinisterly) that if a child doesn’t end up in college or something we consider a career right away, the whole endeavor was pointless. We don’t talk much about “education for education’s sake” anymore. In an increasingly competitive world, this may be the way to go. This mind-set, however, leaves little room for activities that are educationally, but not measurably, valuable.

As arts educators, we constantly have to defend what we do. Art education must earn its place in mainstream classrooms. We have to quantify the value of our discipline through other, more “worthy” goals. People put their kids in theater camp so they can learn how to speak in front of people, enroll them in music classes in response to studies linking music literacy to math scores, and in painting classes to hone their fine-motor skills. But what art can do is so much more than that. Arts education—drama, music, and visual media—offers the most effective vehicles we have to deliver one of the oldest and most central purposes of education: to create citizens who know how to raise their voices in conversation with the world around them, whatever (and in whichever form) that conversation might be. We’re all arts teachers in the sense that we all help children to find their voices and discover who they are.

Education is a gift we give to our children. We can wrap it up as math, science, reading, or art, but the important thing isn’t what we give them. It’s what they do with it. Arts education enables children to develop into who they really are; it’s the key that opens kids’ minds and makes the rest of the stuff possible. Michael’s SpongeBob quip was more prophetic than he knew: you can’t play music on a piece of paper, and you can’t describe the purpose of education on one either.

Alicia “Ali” Arman is a student at the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

Comment on this article
  • Jay P. Greene says:

    Hi Ali,

    Thanks for this piece. I agree that most people have goals for their children’s education that extend beyond being college and career ready. Those broader goals include being culturally literate, socially engaged, and humane in their values. The arts and theater play an important role in achieving these broader goals.

    You are probably familiar with this, but we have rigorous empirical research showing that the arts and theater do in fact produce these outcomes. See for example http://educationnext.org/the-educational-value-of-field-trips/ and http://educationnext.org/learning-live-theater/.

    Thanks again for reminding those interested in education reform that education isn’t entirely or even mostly about maximizing math and reading test scores.

  • Michelle Cockerham says:

    Dear Miss Arman,

    Kudos! for effectively communicating a critical component missing from Common Core! Thank you for articulating the value and necessity of the profitable over the pragmatic. May you spur many to join this conversation lest the arts and our free speech be stifled.

  • Lori Straus says:

    Bang on. I recently interviewed a high school student studying dance, and she was in dance because her grandfather saw a gift in her. It was probably one of the most beautiful things I’d ever heard. Certainly, there are practical gains from studying the arts, but human expression in its multiple forms should be the highest goal.

  • John Butterfield says:

    As one of your former teachers I am so incredibly proud of you. I remember your first class and working with devising for that year. Your courage gave others courage to speak and be heard.
    As a company member of Butterfield 8 you always brought all of yourself to the work.
    Im proud to know you as an articulate woman and friend keep going, your voice is needed.

  • Charlotte Tabereaux, Ph.D. says:

    LOVE your article! You are so RIGHT! :-)

  • Comment on this Article

    Name ()


    Sponsored Results

    The Hoover Institution at Stanford University - Ideas Defining a Free Society

    Harvard Kennedy School Program on Educational Policy and Governance

    Thomas Fordham Institute - Advancing Educational Excellence and Education Reform